Moving up, coming out, moving on

Credit: Drama Queen

I remember what it was like to be acceptable and perfect in the eyes of the church.

I was a deacon, a former music minister, guest preacher and religious education director, raised in a Southern Baptist church by a pastor father. I was moving up and establishing myself as a thoughtful, exuberant voice of wisdom in my church. I earned the maximum amount of love and acceptance because I was doing everything “right.”

But I learned at 34, rather late, that I was gay. So trained to believe that homosexuality was a sin, I nearly took my own life. Thankfully, I didn’t follow through. I decided, instead, to research what God and the scripture said about homosexuality, and to listen to other gay Christians tell their stories. I took three years to weigh everything – I didn’t want to be wrong. Thorough discernment I became convinced that Christians can be gay, and we can have relationships too. Still, the thought of sharing this news with my church gripped me with fear: I could lose my family, my community, my support network, even my identity. Being a Christian is a huge lifestyle choice.

So I waited a few years, getting deeper into church service. It didn’t feel important to come out, except that I was lonely. I felt God telling me to do it – that he couldn’t do much with me closeted. I was petrified. Part of me said it would be okay – that I wasn’t just any gay, I was someone my church family loved.

So I gathered up my courage and I came out family by family, trying to make it personal through three-hour coming out sessions. I cried. They cried. Though I tried to contain the news, it soon charged through the congregation like an electric current. Instantly, all my relationships changed. People felt hurt, betrayed, angry, confused – and a few lept to my side in support. Church elders asked me to swear to lifelong celibacy, but I knew that wasn’t their call. I was forced to resign from service in the church. The congregation was asked to choose between two interpretations of scripture, and they chose a condemning one. We tried for a year and a half to love each other, thinking the other side would see their error. My few church friends didn’t know what to do to help me – not against a whole church and pressure from the denomination. For me, the stress of fighting was too much. Then one day I tried a new church. In the pew I found a thin leaflet that welcomed me as a gay man. It was like someone gave me a cold glass of water. I nearly cried for happiness and relief. I moved to that church. I realized I had almost died of thirst while my church professed to be loving me.

I would come out all over again even knowing what I would lose. I have freedom to speak out, to serve, and to find love. I have my integrity and a new peace. My whole life opened up, but I had to risk losing friends, reputation, respect, and position for it to happen. I never lost God, so I never lost hope.

- Jerome Stueart lives in Whitehorse, Yukon Territory and works as the marketing director for the Yukon Arts Centre. He also maintains a blog of gay Christian resources at

Issue 24

This article first appeared in Geez magazine Issue 24, Winter 2011, The privilege issue.

Like this article? Subscribe to Geez and get more like this delivered to your door, ad-free, four times year.

View comments, or leave one yourself

Hide comments

(The discussion has begun.)

1 Comment

  1. Hey Jerome:

    Thanks for sharing your story of the difficult journey of discovering and then accepting your sexuality. I can only imagine what a relief it was that day you went to that church which had a leaflet specifically welcoming you as you are.

    rob g February 7th, 2012 2:29am

Sorry, comments are closed.

Get Our Newsletter

(Tasteful and spam-free, guaranteed.)

All content is © 2005–2024 Geez Magazine and its respective authors.   (Ascend)

Geez Magazine | 1950 Trumbull Ave. | Detroit, MI, USA | 48216